Fireplace Updates Before and After
Discover stunning transformations that turn outdated fireplaces into modern centerpieces. From simple cosmetic refreshes to full remodels, see what's possible for your home.
SEE TRANSFORMATIONSWhy Fireplace Updates Matter: A fireplace is often the focal point of a living room. An outdated fireplace can date an entire space, while a well-executed update can modernize the room, improve efficiency, and increase your home's value. Whether you're planning a DIY fireplace makeover or hiring a professional, understanding your options is the first step.
Why Update Your Fireplace?
Fireplace updates before and after tell a powerful story of transformation. An old, inefficient, or visually dated fireplace can drag down the aesthetic of an entire room. Updating it not only refreshes the look but can also improve heating efficiency, safety, and usability. Many homeowners find that a fireplace remodel delivers one of the highest returns on investment in terms of visual impact and added home value.
Before you begin, it's helpful to understand the cost breakdown of a fireplace project and the fireplace buying guide to make informed decisions. Whether you're replacing a wood-burning unit with a gas fireplace insert with logs and blower or installing an electric fireplace recessed insert, the transformation can be dramatic.
Before and After Transformations
The following examples illustrate common fireplace updates before and after. Each scenario highlights the problem, the solution, and the resulting transformation.
Painted Brick Fireplace
Before: A dark, dated red brick fireplace dominated the living room, making the space feel heavy and closed-in.
After: The brick was painted in a soft white, instantly brightening the room and creating a modern farmhouse look.
- Low-cost, high-impact transformation
- Completed in a weekend
- Works with any decor style
Electric Insert Installation
Before: An old, non-functional wood-burning fireplace with a soot-stained surround and no realistic flame.
After: An electric fireplace insert into existing fireplace provided realistic flames, supplemental heat, and a clean, modern look.
- No venting or chimney required
- Plug-and-play installation
- Zone heating for energy savings
Related: Electric Fireplace Inserts for Wood Burning Fireplace
Gas Insert Conversion
Before: A drafty, inefficient wood-burning fireplace that was rarely used due to the mess and effort required.
After: A gas fireplace insert with logs and blower delivered instant ambiance and efficient heat at the touch of a button.
- High efficiency and convenience
- Realistic log set and flame
- Thermostat and remote control options
Full Surround and Mantel Remodel
Before: A plain, builder-grade fireplace with a basic wood surround and no visual interest.
After: A custom fireplace non-combustible surround with stacked stone and a solid wood mantel created a stunning focal point.
- Dramatic visual transformation
- Custom design possibilities
- Increased home value
Related: Fireplace Remodel Guide
Double-Sided Fireplace Installation
Before: A single-sided fireplace that only served one room, leaving an adjacent space cold and disconnected.
After: A double-sided fireplace or two-sided see-through electric fireplace connected two rooms, creating a seamless flow and shared ambiance.
- Architectural statement piece
- Multi-room enjoyment
- Custom installation required
Mantel and Accessory Refresh
Before: A functional but bland fireplace with no mantel decor and dated accessories.
After: A new fireplace mantel for gas fireplace paired with antique cast iron fireplace screen and fresh decor transformed the look.
- Budget-friendly refresh
- No structural changes
- Instant visual improvement
Related: Fireplace Accessories Guide
Fireplace Update Options Compared
The table below compares common fireplace update approaches by tier, effort, and impact. Use this to determine which type of update aligns with your goals and resources.
| Update Type | Quality Tier | Effort Level | Visual Impact | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Painting Brick/Stone | Entry-Level | Low (DIY-friendly) | High | Dated brick or stone that needs brightening |
| New Mantel & Accessories | Entry-Level | Low (DIY-friendly) | Medium | Bland fireplace needing character |
| Electric Insert Installation | Mid-Range | Medium (DIY possible) | High | Non-functional or inefficient fireplace |
| Gas Insert Conversion | Mid-Range | Medium (Pro recommended) | High | Wood-burning fireplace needing convenience |
| Surround & Hearth Remodel | Premium | High (Pro recommended) | Very High | Full aesthetic transformation |
| Double-Sided Fireplace | Luxury | Very High (Pro required) | Exceptional | Connecting two rooms with a focal point |
DIY vs Professional Fireplace Updates
Deciding whether to tackle your fireplace update yourself or hire a professional depends on the scope of the project and your comfort level with tools and installation. For a deeper dive, see our guide on DIY vs professional fireplace installation.
DIY-Friendly Updates
These projects are suitable for homeowners with basic DIY skills:
- Painting brick, stone, or tile
- Adding a new mantel
- Installing a DIY fireplace surround for electric fireplace
- Updating hearth accessories
- Installing an electric insert (plug-and-play models)
Related: DIY Fireplace Makeover Guide
Professional-Recommended Updates
These projects require licensed professionals for safety and code compliance:
- Gas insert installation and gas line work
- Chimney liner installation
- Structural changes to the fireplace surround
- Electrical work for hardwired inserts
- Any modification to venting systems
Related: Installing a Fireplace Insert
💡 Pro Tip: Before starting any fireplace update, check local building codes and fireplace permit requirements. Even cosmetic updates may require a permit if they involve electrical or gas work. Always prioritize safety and consult a professional when in doubt.
How to Plan Your Fireplace Update
A successful fireplace update starts with a clear plan. Follow these steps to ensure your project goes smoothly from start to finish.
- Assess Your Current Fireplace: Determine whether it's functional, inefficient, or purely decorative. Identify any safety issues like creosote buildup or damaged components. Use our fireplace inspection checklist to guide your assessment.
- Define Your Goals: Decide what you want from the update—better heating, improved aesthetics, lower maintenance, or all of the above. This will guide your choice between cosmetic updates and full remodels.
- Choose Your Update Type: Select from cosmetic refreshes (painting, new mantel), insert installation (electric, gas, or wood), or full remodel (surround, hearth, and structural changes).
- Set a Realistic Budget: Use tier-based comparisons to estimate costs. Entry-level updates are budget-friendly, mid-range updates involve moderate investment, and premium/luxury updates are high-end. Remember to factor in labor if hiring a professional.
- Gather Materials and Tools: For DIY projects, source high-quality materials like heat-resistant grout for fireplace and fireproof mats for in front of fireplace. For professional projects, get multiple quotes.
- Prepare the Space: Clear the area, protect flooring, and ensure proper ventilation. If installing an insert, measure the firebox carefully to ensure a proper fit.
- Execute the Update: Follow manufacturer instructions for inserts and materials. For complex projects, hire a licensed professional to ensure safety and code compliance.
- Add Finishing Touches: Complete the look with accessories like fireplace screens, fireplace mantels, and decor. Consider a smart Wi-Fi fireplace controller for modern convenience.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
❌ Ignoring Venting Requirements
Different fireplace types have different venting needs. A gas insert requires proper gas fireplace venting requirements, while ventless models have specific ventilation requirements. Always verify before installation.
❌ Using Non-Heat-Resistant Materials
Regular tile, grout, or paint can crack or discolor when exposed to heat. Always use heat-resistant grout and non-combustible materials like fireplace non-combustible surround panels.
❌ Skipping Professional Installation
Gas and electrical work should be handled by licensed professionals. Improper installation can lead to safety hazards, void warranties, and fail inspections. See our guide on installing gas fireplace insert in existing fireplace.
❌ Overlooking Clearance Requirements
Fireplaces require specific clearances from combustible materials. Learn about furniture distance from fireplace and TV above fireplace safety to prevent hazards.
After Your Fireplace Update
Once your fireplace update is complete, proper maintenance ensures it remains beautiful and functional for years to come. Regular fireplace maintenance and annual fireplace inspection are essential. Depending on your fireplace type, follow specific care guides such as electric fireplace maintenance, gas fireplace maintenance, or wood fireplace maintenance.
For troubleshooting common issues after your update, refer to our fireplace troubleshooting hub. Whether it's a gas fireplace won't light issue or an electric fireplace not heating problem, we have solutions.
Ready to Transform Your Fireplace?
Explore our recommended fireplaces and inserts below to find the perfect fit for your update project.
VIEW RECOMMENDED PRODUCTS
