Electric Fireplace Insert for Wood Burning Fireplace

If you have a traditional wood burning fireplace that sits unused for most of the year, you are not alone. Many homeowners love the look and history of their fireplace but find the work of chopping wood, building fires, and cleaning ash to be a barrier to regular use. An electric fireplace insert for a wood burning fireplace is the perfect solution. This guide will walk you through everything you need to know about this popular home improvement project.

An electric insert is a self-contained unit that fits directly into the opening of your existing masonry or prefabricated fireplace. It provides the ambiance of a real fire and can also serve as an effective supplemental heat source, all without the mess, smell, or maintenance of a wood fire. For a deeper look at the different types available, you can explore our guide on electric fireplace inserts.

The decision to convert is often driven by a desire for convenience and efficiency. Here are the primary benefits:

• Installation is Easy: Unlike gas inserts, which require a gas line and professional installation, electric inserts are often a plug-and-play solution. You can typically install one yourself in under an hour, with no need for a chimney, venting, or major construction. This is a major reason why many people choose an electric fireplace insert for an existing fireplace.
• No Mess, No Fuss: You get the visual appeal of a fire without the need to purchase, store, or chop firewood. There is no ash to clean up, no soot on your walls, and no chimney to sweep.
• Energy Efficient Zone Heating: Electric inserts are 100% efficient at converting electricity into heat. They are excellent for zone heating, allowing you to warm the room you are in while lowering the thermostat for the rest of the house. This can lead to significant savings on your energy bills.
• Safe and Clean: Electric inserts produce no carbon monoxide, no smoke, and no creosote. This makes them a safer option for indoor air quality. You can learn more about this in our article on whether electric fireplaces produce carbon monoxide.
• Year-Round Enjoyment: You can enjoy the flame effect with or without heat, making it perfect for creating ambiance in any season.

For a broader comparison of how electric fireplaces stack up against other types, see our guide on electric vs gas fireplaces.

Selecting the right insert involves a few key considerations to ensure it meets your needs and fits your space.

1. Sizing and Fit

This is the most critical step. Measure the front opening (width and height), the back opening, and the depth of your fireplace. The insert should fit comfortably within these dimensions. You also need to consider the hearth depth to ensure the insert doesn't protrude too far into the room. For smaller fireplaces, you might need to look for an electric fireplace insert for small spaces.

2. Heating Capacity (BTU)

The heating power of an electric insert is measured in British Thermal Units (BTUs). A general rule of thumb is to have about 30-60 BTUs per square foot of space you want to heat, depending on insulation and climate. Most inserts range from 4,000 to 5,200 BTUs, which is sufficient for zone heating a room up to 400 square feet. To calculate your specific needs, use our fireplace BTU calculator.

3. Flame Realism and Features

Modern electric inserts offer incredibly realistic flames. Look for features like:

• LED Flame Technology: Offers a bright, clear, and energy-efficient flame effect.
• Adjustable Flame Colors and Brightness: Allows you to customize the look.
• Crackling Sound: Adds to the ambiance. You can find models with crackling sound effects.
• Remote Control and Thermostat: For convenient operation. A model with a remote control and a thermostat is highly recommended.

4. Quality Tiers

Electric inserts are available in various quality tiers. Entry-level models offer basic flame effects and heating. Mid-range models often provide more realistic flames, better build quality, and more features like thermostats and remotes. Premium and luxury models feature the most advanced flame technology, superior materials, and smart home connectivity.

One of the biggest advantages of an electric insert is the straightforward installation. Here is a general overview:

1. Preparation: Ensure the fireplace is clean and free of debris. If you have a gas line, it must be capped by a professional. For a wood fireplace, you may want to have the chimney capped to prevent drafts and animal entry. You can read about how to stop cold air from coming down your chimney.
2. Positioning: Carefully slide the electric insert into the fireplace opening. It's a good idea to have a helper for this step.
3. Leveling: Use the adjustable leveling legs (if provided) to ensure the unit is stable and level.
4. Securing (Optional): Some units can be secured to the fireplace opening with screws or brackets for added stability.
5. Power: Plug the unit into a standard, grounded electrical outlet. Avoid using an extension cord if possible. If you need a new outlet, consider hiring an electrician.

The entire process is significantly simpler than converting to a gas insert. If you're wondering about the complexity of a professional installation, you can read more about how long fireplace installation takes.

How does an electric insert compare to other ways of updating a wood burning fireplace?

While a gas insert may be more powerful, the simplicity and safety of an electric insert are often the deciding factors. You can also explore the possibility of converting your wood burning fireplace to electric, which is the specific project this guide covers.

Electric inserts are very low maintenance, but a few simple steps will keep it running safely and efficiently for years.

• Cleaning: Dust the exterior and vents regularly. Clean the glass screen with a soft, damp cloth. For more detailed instructions, see our guide on cleaning an electric fireplace.
• Inspection: Periodically check the power cord for damage and ensure the plug is secure. An annual electric fireplace inspection is a good practice.
• Safety: Keep flammable materials away from the unit. Ensure the fireplace is on a stable surface. For more safety information, read our electric fireplace safety tips.

Converting your wood burning fireplace with an electric insert is a smart, cost-effective way to breathe new life into a cherished feature of your home. It offers the perfect blend of ambiance, convenience, and efficient heating without the hassle and maintenance of a traditional fire. By following the guidance in this article, you can make an informed decision and enjoy your fireplace more than ever before.

Ready to find the perfect insert for your home? Check out our top recommendations below.